Voluntary lobotomy used to be an oxymoron
I find it interesting to observe my own progress while learning new skills. The early lesson of that process taught me how early challenges build in us foundational skills. They make us see the nature of the problem differently - they show us what matters and what has a minimal impact on the end result. With time we integrate these skills. They become a part of us. Their impact on our work is huge while they feels small. They become small because they stop being external entities, but integral parts of us.
I used to do a lot of 3D modelling, especially sculpting, using ZBrush. Art is one of those fields in which progress creeps in. Your goal is to show up. Months, years into the process you can look back and see the progress you’ve made. That progress will come faster the more you reflect on your mistakes. You can however observe that you can achieve better results with less work. That’s because you learn what makes the biggest impact. In 3D modelling you quickly move from more geometry to less geometry. It’s easier to work with less vertices because you’re looking for an appealing form. No amount of detail will save a bad form. There’s no point in zooming in and fixing details - it doesn’t impact the final result the same way an interesting form does. With time you might choose to focus on form and ignore detail, only because you’ve explored both and decided one of those appeals to you more. You become more comfortable with bigger and bigger changes. It’s less and less intimidating. Your movements become bigger, which in turn allows you to explore different ideas further and do it faster.
I see a similar pattern when programming. Nowadays I often use custom allocators to handle certain memory management tasks. I allocate memory for it at the start and never release it. That strategy allows me to focus on other, more impactful things. Memory management logic can be always swapped to something more fitting. The focus of my work lies elsewhere. Identifying how much effort to put where is a skill reflecting ones experience. Experience makes you focus on what matters, while giving you confidence needed to revisit the, previously unimportant, parts of the project.
Try writing. When I write I can see myself thinking slowly, moving in small steps. I think in terms of correct words, correct sentences, not in terms of paragraphs. Experienced writers think bigger. It’s not about correct sentences, not about correct paragraphs or correct chapters. It’s more than that. They’re past correctness. The entire piece has a coherent through line. The craft is there, in them, not as a separate task they have to focus on.
Learning changes you and changes how you see the world around you. Writing makes you a better reader. Reading makes you a better writer. You see more, your experiences become deeper.
How does that fit in the world full of AI?
Jensen Huang said that kids don’t need to learn math anymore. It’s a weird statement since counting devices and machines have been with us for a while. The generative AI and LLMs aren’t good tools for math per se. The way I see it, Huang tries to say that people won’t be doing math at work anymore. I think everything these people say should be viewed through the lens of economy and employer, employee relationship. The AI has exposed something we knew, but rarely admitted: employers don’t want you to learn on the job, if they can they’ll bypass you, and extract out of you that what produces value. You, your salary, your vacation plans, it’s all just in the way.
I wonder how would Jensen feel if his children, both currently employed at Nvidia, couldn’t do basic math…
I do not want to focus on what learning means in terms of your job prospects and job security. Job market periodically dips its toes in the “kill or be killed” philosophy. It’s a different world, only interested in workers well being if it impacts their stock value.
I do see AI as a poison to the learning process, lead in your school’s walls. It’ll rob young people of the self improvement through learning. Their units of expression will stay small. Their war of art will be to write correct sentences, instead of beautiful novels. Assuming they’ll even try.
None of the arguments, brought up by the AI enthusiasts, convince me it’ll sort itself out. AI isn’t the new calculator. This argument that it’s just a tool is hollow. Is a nuclear bomb just a tool? Tools impact us and our society. Is it inconceivable that AI will impact it in a big, negative way? Is it naive to think young people will reach for AI anytime they face a challenge, like homework?
Between us and the techno feudalism stands our reading comprehension, our knowledge, our skills, our exercised ability to look deeper, past the surface layer.
I find the world incredibly interesting and decoding it gives me a lot of personal satisfaction. Exercising my learning abilities builds my confidence and allows me to think bigger ideas. The process is the purpose, as we are the process.